Pure Guardian vs Homedics Humidifiers [Comparison & Recommendations]

Pure Guardian vs Homedics Humidifiers - Which humidifier is better?

Guardian Technologies showed great commitment to tackling excessively dry air when they introduced their first humidifier series many years ago. The company claims its sole mission is to help people live healthier and happier lives by offering innovative, powerful and safe technologies.

With their humidifiers- christened Pure Guardian- the company is doing its bit to help reduce excess indoor moisture and prevent the discomfort, irritation and diseases that come with it. But, just how good are they?

On the other hand, Homedics humidifiers are manufactured by Homedics Technologies. The 30-year old brand relies on time-tested science and innovation in its bid to lead the charge for healthier homes and ensure that homeowners can effectively deal with issues like indoor air dryness.

But, just how well do their humidifiers perform? This post is a comparison of Pure Guardian and Homedics humidifiers, and we’ll show you all the specific features that make each of them unique.

Pure Guardian Vs Homedics Humidifiers [Comparison Summary]

1Types of HumidifiersTie
4Tank CapacityPure Guardian
5Coverage AreaTie
6Ease of UseTie
8User ReviewsPure Guardian

Pure Guardian Vs Homedics Humidifiers [Detail Comparison of Important Features]

1. Different Types of Humidifiers from Pure Guardian and Homedics

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
Mostly ultrasonic humidifiers, Cool Mist and Warm and Cool Mist units.  

Some units are evaporative in design and operation. Table-top and floor units. Portable units are available.      

All units are domestic and should only designed for indoors; at home or in your office.
Also has mostly ultrasonic units, Cool Mist, as well as Warm and Cool Mist units. Most units are also evaporative in design. These units are also table-top and floor-placed.

They have even more portable and smaller, personal units for smaller spaces.   Units are meant for homes, spaces, offices and for dedicated areas as well.

Both Pure Guardian and Homedics humidifiers have invested in quite a number of models to help people with different needs add moisture to their indoor air. They both offer Ultrasonic, Cool, and Warm and Cool Mist Humidifiers.

However, some units by Homedics are meant for really small spaces and are more portable. For this category, both brands have mostly similar types of units and are both highly recommended by us for small, medium and some large spaces.

Winner: Tie

2. Humidifier filters [Pure Guardian Vs Homedics]

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
Pure Guardian Humidifiers do not feature filters, wicking filters or even evaporating pads.   Includes Anti-mode or mildew protection to keep moisture clean and free from contamination.Homedics units, on the other hand, have a cotton filter in many of their units.   Here, you’ll find demineralization cartridges instead to prevent mineral buildup and malfunction.

As for filters, Pure Guardian units do not have them but Homedics have some sort of filters known as Cotton filters. To prevent water contamination, both units have some sort of protection to ensure water and air released into the room are clean and safe for breathing.

We would announce Homedics as the winner here, but Pure Guardian’s Silver Clean Protection is also pretty effective and deserve a mention here.

Winner: Tie

Pure Guardian Humidifier with Best Filter: The PureGuardian H1510 ultrasonic cool mist humidifier

Homedics Humidifier with Best Filter: HoMedics TotalComfort Deluxe Ultrasonic Air Humidifier

3. Durability [What is the long lasting humidifier – Pure Guardian or Homedics?]

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
Pure Guardian has fairly durable humidifiers, built with plastic in most cases.

They have anti-mold technology to protect your units from damage and keep them running for long.  

Their units have an average lifespan of 5 to 10 years. Some models do not last as long.   An average of 1-3 warranty on its units.
Homedics humidifiers are also quite durable, probably as durable as Pure Guardian units. Demineralization cartridge helps to keep water tank protected for long-lasting use.  

For Homedics humidifiers, the average lifespan is between 3 and 10 years, depending on the model of the unit.   Homedics units have a standard warranty of about 2 years.

Although very popular, durability is not one of the strong points of both Pure Guardian and Homedics humidifiers.

Don’t get us wrong, their units pack up some strength and will keep going for a number of years as long as they’re properly maintained, but they do not rank in the top 5 of most durable humidifier brands. However, we’ll provide a recommendation of two standout units, one from each brand.

Winner: Tie

Longest Lasting Pure Guardian Humidifier: Pure Guardian H910BL Ultrasonic Cool Mist Humidifier

Longest Lasting Homedics Humidifier: HoMedics TotalComfort Deluxe Ultrasonic Humidifier

4. Humidifier Water Tank Capacity [Pure Guardian Vs Homedics]

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
Pure Guardian Humidifiers have different sizes with corresponding tank capacities. They range from 0.5 gallons to 2 gallons in water capacity.Homedics have some really small units that Pure Guardian doesn’t, and they have a water tank capacity of between 0.07 gallons to about 1.5 gallons.

Generally, Pure Guardian has units that are larger and will run for longer periods due to their large water tanks.

On average, their units have a 1-1.5 gallon water tank, while those of Homedics have an average water tank of less than a gallon. For this reason, we’ll declare Pure Guardian the winner of this category.

Winner: Pure Guardian

Pure Guardian Humidifier with Large Tank Capacity: Pure Guardian H4810AR Ultrasonic Warm and Cool Mist Humidifier

5. Coverage Area [How much area do Pure Guardian and Homedics humidifiers cover?]

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
Pure Guardian Humidifiers are not the largest on the market, in terms of coverage. On average, they cover spaces between 170 sq. ft to as much as 650 sq. ft.  

Different units suitable for dorm room, small bedroom, large bedroom, living room, office, storeroom, and several other indoor spaces not exceeding 650 sq. ft.
Homedics humidifiers are even smaller in terms of product categories. You’ll find units that cover spaces beginning at about 100 sq. ft to as large as 550 sq. ft.  

Just like Pure Guardian, Homedics units can be deployed in small, medium and large spaces, including a dorm room, study, work desk, small room, bedroom and even living room.

Overall, both brands have units that will serve your average-sized room humidity needs. Some are also pretty good for large rooms. Pure Guardian, however, has a few units larger than those of the largest Homedics products.

This means there are some spaces for which you’ll find a Pure Guardian humidifier but you won’t find a Homedics unit.

However, we must recognize that there are times you’ll need really small units for spots like vehicles and so on. Homedics will come through in such cases.

Winner: Tie

Pure Guardian Humidifier with Best Coverage Area: Pure Guardian H4750AR Ultrasonic Cool Mist Humidifier

Homedics Humidifier with Best Coverage Area: HoMedics TotalComfort® Deluxe Ultrasonic Air Humidifier

6. Ease of Use/Design

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
All units use Touch Control, with LED Display and electronic control features. They have buttons and levers for easy manipulation.    

A few of them combine touch control and remote control, but this is not common among Pure Guardian units. Most units have an easily removable, transparent water tank for easy monitoring of water levels.
Homedics humidifiers also feature Touch control on all units, except for the Elecameier Warm and Cool Mist Humidifier that uses only remote control.  

Some other units also have a remote control feature with LED displays for apt monitoring. Many of its units also feature clear water tanks so users can monitor the water levels. They are also easily removable.

It is clear that both brands are pretty ergonomic and easy to use. The buttons and touch displays are easy to understand and manipulate.

Also, many of their units have tanks that can be easily pulled away from the unit and emptied. Some also feature remote control and enhance your convenience. Both brands share the spoils in this category.

Winner: Tie

Easy to Use Pure Guardian Humidifier: Guardian Technologies Pure Guardian H940 Ultrasonic Cool Mist Humidifier

Easy to Use Homedics Humidifier: HoMedics TotalComfort Plus Ultrasonic Air Humidifier

7. Price [What is the cheapest humidifier – Pure Guardian or Homedics?]

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
Pure Guardian humidifiers are generally affordable and some of its units are budget-friendly. The products range from about $25 to around $160, from the smallest to the most expensive units.    

Most of its units also feature aromatherapy pads and essential oils cost between $10 and $30, depending on how much you need.
On the other hand are Homedics humidifiers, which cost around $20-$130 on average for its different types and models. This also shows great affordability.

However, units of the same capacity as Pure Guardian are slightly higher in price. Also, some of the units feature aromatherapy pads and would require a similar budget for that.

Overall, Pure Guardian humidifiers are slightly more affordable in price. If you compare its units side-by-side with those of Homedics, you’ll find that prices of units of the same category tend to be lower in the Pure Guardian line.

This is not to say that Homedics are not affordable. In fact, some of the cheapest Humidifiers on the market are produced by Homedics.

Another very important aspect is, if you are looking for portable personal humidifiers, Homedics offers excellent options at a price of as low as $20.

Final Verdict:

  • For general humidifiers, Pure Guardian wins the battle with respect to low price.
  • For portable personal humidifiers, Homedics is the winner.
  • Overall, Homedics offers the lowest price humidifier.

Winner: Pure Guardian for Regular Humidifiers & Homedics for Personal Humidifiers

Cheapest Pure Guardian Humidifier: Pure Guardian H965AR Ultrasonic Cool Mist Humidifier

Cheapest Homedics Personal Humidifier: HoMedics TotalComfort Portable Ultrasonic Humidifier

8. User Reviews

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
Overall, Pure Guardian Humidifiers have very positive user reviews across parameters like ease of use, noise level, durability, and so on.  

They have been able to gather almost 12,000 reviews on the leading online marketplace, with a rating of 4.4 stars out of 5, on average.
Homedics humidifiers, on the other hand, are not as highly reviewed as Pure Guardian units, using the same parameters.  

The products have a lower number of reviews on the leading online marketplace, currently just under 4,000, with an average rating of 4.1 stars out of 5.

There’s truly no contest here. Pure Guardian humidifiers are better rated than Homedics humidifiers, especially on amazon. Their 12,000 reviews at a 4.4 star average give them an edge over the 4.1 star rating across less then 4,000 reviews by users of Homedics.

Winner: Pure Guardian

Top Pure Guardian Humidifier with Best User Reviews: Pure Guardian H965AR Ultrasonic Cool Mist Humidifier

9. Customer Service and Support

Pure Guardian HumidifiersHomedics Humidifiers
Pure Guardian humidifiers have an average 2-year warranty on all its units. This covers its parts and repairs for the stated period. Many of them also come with a 30-day Return Policy.  

There are post-sale resources like instruction manuals, FAQs, Customer Service Contact Information, a phone number and an email address, support@guardiantechnologies.com for inquiries, questions and complaints. All of these are available on the company’s website.
Just like Pure Guardian, Homedics humidifiers also come with a 2-year warranty which covers repairs and parts. There’s also a Return Policy for a period of 30 days at most.  

If you want support or have complaints on any humidifier, you’ll find a Help and FAQs section and a Customer Support page that features Instruction Book, Live Assistance, a phone number, customer support form, and an email address, cservice@homedics.com on their website.

For us, these two brands have a pretty good customer support system. While there are a few complaints about slow and inefficient customer service in a handful of cases, customers are satisfied overall.

Other Comparative Features of Pure Guardian and Homedics Humidifiers

 Pure GuardianHomedics
Aromatherapy PadYes, in most unitsYes, in some units
Auto Timer/Shut-offYesYes
HumidistatNot present in all unitsAlso not present in all units.
Mist Speed ControlYes, up to 3 Mist settings in most unitsYes, usually 2-3 Mist settings in its units
Water Indicator LightAvailable in some unitsNot a common feature among Homedics humidifiers.

Final Words:

This is a battle between two truly powerful and industry-leading brands. The tight comparison has only been able to show just how much thought the manufacturers put into their products.

Truth is, whatever brand you decide to go with, you’ll be getting a lot of value for your money. With some clear and specific differences between Pure Guardian and Homedics, we believe it is easier for you to choose what works for you.

Photo Title Buy
LEVOIT Air Purifier...image LEVOIT Air Purifier for Home & Bedroom - For Allergies and Pets Hair Check Price On Amazon
BREEZOME 60 OZ...image BREEZOME 60 OZ Quiet Dehumidifiers for Home, Dual-Semiconductor Check Price On Amazon
AquaOasis® Cool Mist...image AquaOasis™ Cool Mist Quiet Ultrasonic Humidifier for Bedroom & Large room Check Price On Amazon
43.3'' Portable Air...image 43.3'' Portable Air Conditioners, 3-IN-1 Evaporative Air Cooler w/Remote Check Price On Amazon
BlueDri BD-AS-550-BL Negative...image BlueDri BD-AS-550-BL Negative Machine Airbourne Cleaner HEPA Air Scrubber Check Price On Amazon
Space Heater,VCK 24 Space Heater, VCK 24" 12ft/s Fast Quiet Heating Portable Electric Heater Check Price On Amazon